This is an outdated version published on 19-10-2022. Read the most recent version.

Оголтелая борьба (интервенция в юридическую науку и перепетии проведенной в Тбилиси 30-х годах «дискуссии») советчины против истинной юридической научной мысли в 30-х годах XX столетия

Authors

  • Marina Garishvili
  • Tornike Nemstsveridze

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.34858/api.1.2022.2

Abstract

Summary

 

The process of occupation and forced Sovietization of Georgia affected all spheres of the social life of the conquered country, including science and culture. The greatest harm was caused to Georgian legal science, which, in the pre-Soviet period, was developed under the ideological influence of advanced European thoughts. Georgian legal scholars, who were educated in prestigious European educational institutions, in their works reflected the achievements of various theories and schools of their Western teachers and colleagues. In the early 30s, Soviet functionaries of all stripes launched a fierce struggle against those progressive thinkers who did not accept the doctrine of Marxism-Leninism "about the dictatorship of the proletariat and violence against the class enemy" and, with the aim of their social isolation, held the so-called "scientific discussion," which had devastating consequences and ended with irreparable damage to Georgian legal thought: many representatives of legal science were killed, or for many years, were forced to obey party dogmas to the detriment of true scientific thought.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Nacional’nyj Arhiv Gruzii, Central’nyj arhiv Novejshej istorii, fond 336, op. 1, delo 124, list 10 (na gruz. jaz).
View in Google Scholar

Nacional’nyj Arhiv Gruzii, Central’nyj arhiv Novejshej istorii, fond 336, op. 3, delo 130, list 64 (na gruz. jaz).
View in Google Scholar

Nacional’nyj Arhiv Gruzii, Central’nyj arhiv Novejshej istorii, fond 471, op. 3, delo 296, list 11 (na gruz. jaz).
View in Google Scholar

Nacional’nyj Arhiv Gruzii, Central’nyj arhiv Novejshej istorii, fond 471, op. 3, delo 296, list 16 (na gruz. jaz).
View in Google Scholar

Nacional’nyj Arhiv Gruzii, Central’nyj arhiv Novejshej istorii, fond 471, op. 3, delo 296, list 1 (na gruz. jaz).
View in Google Scholar

Nacional’nyj Arhiv Gruzii, Central’nyj arhiv Novejshej istorii, fond 471, op. 19, delo 422, list 52 (na gruz. jaz).
View in Google Scholar

Nacional’nyj Arhiv Gruzii, Central’nyj arhiv Novejshej istorii, fond 471, op. 3, delo 296, list 4 (na gruz. jaz).
View in Google Scholar

Nacional’nyj Arhiv Gruzii, Central’nyj arhiv Novejshej istorii, fond 471, op. 3, delo 104, list 4 (na gruz. jaz).
View in Google Scholar

Nacional’nyj Arhiv Gruzii, Central’nyj arhiv Novejshej istorii, fond 471, op. 19, delo 422, list 52 (na gruz. jaz).
View in Google Scholar

Manifest Kommunisticheskoj partii.
View in Google Scholar

Agenture Lominadze v literature (gruppirovka Tatulova, Vol'skogo i drugih), gazeta «Komunisti», № 283, 3 dekabrja 1930 goda .
View in Google Scholar

Bochorishvili I., Marksizm i ugolovnoe pravo (prestuplenie i nakazanie), Tiflis 1932 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Cereteli T., Zhvanija G., Pravovaja nauka, [v:] Nauka v Sovetskoj Gruzi na protjazhenii 40 let, Tbilisi 1961 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Chihladze N., Gruzinskie zhenshhiny – pisateli i obshhestvennye dejateli, Tbilisi 1990 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Cicishvili G., Bol’shoj terror i Ivanje Dzhavahishvili, Tbilisi 2016 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Dzhavahishvili Iv., Pozornye stranicy istorii Gruzii, [v:] Ivanje Dzhavahishvili, chelovek izmenivshij razum Gruzii, Publisticheskij ocherk 1, sotavitel’ i redaktor sbornika N. Kakulija, Tbilisi 2015, s. 50 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Dzhorbenadze S., Kratkaja istorija Tbilisskogo Gosudarstvennogo Universiteta, Tbilisi 1988 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Filosofija i social’nye nauki v Sovetskoj Gruzii, «Vestnik Akademii Nauk GSSR, serija filosofii, psihologii, jekonomiki i prava» 1971, № 1.
View in Google Scholar

Gamkrelidze O., Po povodu novogo izdanija knigi Al. Vacheishvili «Obshhaja teorija prava», [v:] Al. Vacheishvili, Obshhaja teorija prava, vtoroe izdanie, red. O. Gamkrelidze, M. Marinashvili, Tbilisi 2010, VII (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Gokieli F., Civilisticheskie Shtudii, Vospominanija, T. Ninidze, Vvodnie pis’mo, red. K. Antadze, T. Ninidze i M. Ugrehelidze, Tbilisi 2017 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Gokieli F., Luarsab Andronikashvili, «Zhurnal Associacij Gruzinskih juridicheskih firm» 2017, № 3 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Guruli V., Fizionomija krasnoj professury Universiteta (vremja, javlenie, ljudi), [v:] Ivanje Dzhavahishvili – chelovek, kotoryj izmenil razum Gruzii, sostav. sbornika i red. N. Kakulija, Tbilisi 2015 (na gruz. jaz).
View in Google Scholar

Guruli V., Kak Akakij Shanidze vystupil v zashhitu Ivanje Dzhavahishvili ot sudilishha tiranov, [v:] Akakij Shanidze 130 – Chelovek gruzinskogo dela, Publisticheskij ocherk 4, sotavitel’ i redaktor sbornika N. Kakulija, Tbilisi 2017 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Guruli V., Raspjatyj i raspjavshie, Istorija otverzhenija Il’i (1861-1937), Tbilisi 2008 (na gruz. jaz.)
View in Google Scholar

Hvadagiani I., Nepolnyj spisok gruzinskih pisatelej, repressirovannyh v 1921-1938 gg, [v:] Topografija terrora, Sovetskij Tbilisi, red. N. Lezhava, L. Bakradze, vtor. izdanie, Laboratorija issledovanija sovetskogo proshlogo, Tbilisi 2017 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Imedadze I., Uznadze i sovetskaja ideologija, [v:] Dimitrij Uznadze – dusha ne vedaet postojanstvo i izmenchivost’, Publisticheskij ocherk 3, sotavitel’ i redaktor sbornika N. Kakulija, Tbilisi 2016 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Inckirveli G., Juridicheskie nauki, [v:] Tbilisskij Gosudarstvennyj Universitet im. Stalina k 40-letiju Velikoj Oktjabr’skoj socialisticheskoj revoljucii, Tbilisi 1957 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Kak izgnali iz Tbilisskogo Universiteta ego sozdatelja – akad. Iv. Dzhavahishvili, Pozornye stranicy istorii Gruzii, [v:] Ivanje Dzhavahishvili, chelovek izmenivshij razum Gruzii, Publisticheskij ocherk 1, sotavitel’ i redaktor sbornika N. Kakulija, Tbilisi 2015 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Marinashvili M., Ot redaktora, [v:] Al. Vacheishvili, Obshaja teorija prava, Vvedenie v sociologiju, red. M. Marinashvili, Tbilisi 2017, IV (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Naneishvili G., «Dejstvitel’nost’ prava i popytka obosnovanija juridicheskih faktov» Tbilisi, izd-vo Z. Kordadze, 2019 (pervaja publikacija v 1929) (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Nepolnyj spisok gruzinskih pisatelej, repressirovannyh v 1921-1938 gg, podgotovil I. Hvadagiani, [v:] Topografija terrora, Sovetskij Tbilisi, red. N. Lezhav, L. Bakradze, vtor. izdanie, Laboratorija issledovanija sovetskogo proshlogo, Tbilisi 2017, s. 163 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

O polozhenii del i zadachah, sozdannyh v Associaciah proletarskih pisatelej Gruzii i Zakavkaz’ja, gazeta «Komunisti», 6 dekabrja 1930 goda.
View in Google Scholar

Ob Associaciah proletarskih pisatelej Gruzii, gazeta «Komunisti», 2 dekabrja 1930 goda.
View in Google Scholar

old.ihst.ru/projects/sohist/repress/don/1937/bolotnikov.htm [дocтуп: 2.01.2019]
View in Google Scholar

Otkrytyj spisok, Bolotnikov Aleksej Aleksandrovich (1894), ru.openlist.wiki/%D0%91%D0%BE%D0%BB%D0%BE%D1%82%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B2_%D0%90%D0%BB%D0%B5%D0%BA%D1%81%D0%B5%D0%B9_%D0%90%D0%BB%D0%B5%D0%BA%D1%81%D0%B0%D0%BD%D0%B4%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%B8%D1%87_(1894) [дocтуп: 2.01.2019]
View in Google Scholar

Plotnieks A., Obshhaja teorija prava v 1929-1931 gg.: razvitie, diskussii, konsolidacija. Socialisticheskaja revoljucija i pravovaja ideologija, respublikanskij mezhvuzovskij sbornik nauchnyj trudov, red. V.O. Miller, Riga 1977.
View in Google Scholar

Postanovlenie CIK «O sozdanii Instituta Marksizma-Leninizma», Sbornik Zakonov i rasporjazhenij Raboche-Krest’janskogo pravitel’stva Gruzinskoj Sovetskoj Socialisticheskoj Respubliki, № 2, ch. 1, 31 janvarja 1931 goda, s. 35.
View in Google Scholar

Predsedateli Verhovnogo Suda Gruzii, www.supremecourt.ge/palace-of-justice/chairperson-of-the-supreme-court/ [дocтуп: 30.12.2018].
View in Google Scholar

Savaneli B., Diskussija ili avantjura, ili kak gotovilis’ respressii 30-h godov protiv gruzinskih uchenyh, «Sovetskoj pravo» 1989, №5, s. 43–49 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Shonija V.N., «Istoki zla, ili kak sfal’sificirovali «megrel’skoe delo», www.opentext.org.ge/index.php?m=69&y=2002&art=13159 [дocтуп: 30.12.2018].
View in Google Scholar

Sigua S., Martvili i Alamdari, tom I, Tbilisi 2003 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Slovar’ Gruzinskih filosofov, Personalija, Tbilisi 2000 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Soselija G.K., K voprosu o proishozhdenii gosudarstva, Tfilisi 1934 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

«Sovetskoe pravo» 1974, № 5, s. 96 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Spisok lic, vhodivshih v sostav troek, sozdannyh po prikazu NKVD SSSR ot 30.07.1937 #00447, nkvd.memo.ru/index.php/%D0%94%D0%BE%D0%BA%D1%83%D0%BC%D0%B5%D0%BD%D1%82:%D0%A1%D0%BE%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B0%D0%B2%D1%8B_%D1%82%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B5%D0%BA_%D0%B2_1937%E2%88%921938_%D0%B3%D0%BE%D0%B4%D0%B0%D1%85 [дocтуп: 30.12.2018].
View in Google Scholar

Spravochnik po istorii Kommunisticheskoj partii i Sovetskogo Sojuza 1898-1991, www.knowbysight.info/LLL/11882.asp [дocтуп: 23.03.2019].
View in Google Scholar

Stalinskie rasstrel’nye spiski iz Gruzii, Gegenava Aleksandr Ivanovich, www.nplg.gov.ge/gwdict/index.php?a=term&d=26&t=3522 [дocтуп: 29.12.2018].
View in Google Scholar

Stalinskie rasstrel’nye spiski iz Gruzii, Tumanov Leon Georgievich, www.nplg.gov.ge/gwdict/index.php?a=term&d=26&t=4123 [дocтуп: 3.01.2019].
View in Google Scholar

Stalinskie rasstrel’nye spiski, stalin.memo.ru/names/p365.htm [дocтуп: 31.12.2018].
View in Google Scholar

Surguladze Ir., “Gewalt und Recht” (vlast’ i pravo), perevod s nemeckogo jazyka O. Gamkrelidze, red. G. Hubua, Tbilisi 2002 (na gruz. jaz.) (pervaja redakcija na nemeckom v 1925 g.)
View in Google Scholar

Surguladze Ir., Pravo, [v:] Nauka v Sovetskoj Gruzii na protjazhenii 25 let, tom III, Tbilisi 1946 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Toradze M., «Ot «vreditel’stva» – do akademichnosti» – put’, projdennyj gazetoj, «Gazeta Tbilisskogo universiteta» 2013, 25 aprelja, №5 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Vacheishvili Al., Obshhaja teorija prava, vtoroe izdanie, red. O. Gamkrelidze, M. Marinashvili, Tbilisi 2010, VII (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

www.parliament.ge/files/sxdomebi/1937dep/barigiani.doc [дocтуп: 1.01.2019].
View in Google Scholar

www.parliament.ge/files/sxdomebi/1951dep/barigiani.doc [дocтуп: 1.01.2019].
View in Google Scholar

www.parliament.ge/files/sxdomebi/1937dep/barigiani.doc [дocтуп: 1.01.2019].
View in Google Scholar

www.parliament.ge/files/sxdomebi/1951dep/barigiani.doc [дocтуп: 1.01.2019].
View in Google Scholar

www.parliament.ge/files/sxdomebi/1959dep/barigiani.doc [дocтуп: 1.01.2019].
View in Google Scholar

www.sakharov-center.ru/asfcd/martirolog/?t=page&id=4096 [дocтуп: 2.01.2019].
View in Google Scholar

Zapreshhennaja literatura, [v:] Osmyslenie sovetskogo proshlogo, diskussii – 2011, red. N. Bekishvili, N. Lezhava, Tbilisi 2012 (na gruz. jaz.).
View in Google Scholar

Downloads

Published

19-10-2022 — Updated on 19-10-2022

Versions

How to Cite

Garishvili, Marina, and Tornike Nemstsveridze. 2022. “Оголтелая борьба (интервенция в юридическую науку и перепетии проведенной в Тбилиси 30-х годах «дискуссии») советчины против истинной юридической научной мысли в 30-х годах XX столетия”. Annales Pomorienses. Ius, no. 1 (October). https://doi.org/10.34858/api.1.2022.2.