Comparative Analysis of Wine Production Regulations in parallel to the creation of the European Union and the Collapse of the Soviet Union in Oldest Wine Producing Country -Georgia and Biggest Wine Producing Country - France
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.34858/api.1.2022.8Keywords:
Comparative Analysis, Wine Production Regulations, European Union, France, Soviet Union, GeorgiaAbstract
France and Georgia are intentionally selected as two case studies for the purposes of the present article. The major reason for this derives from the history and traditions of wine making and its regulation existent in the two countries.
Georgia with its ancient wine making traditions, is the birthplace of wine (“cradle of wine”),[1] World's oldest wine was discovered in Georgia in 8 000 years old jars, as evidence of the oldest example of the domestication of a wildly growing vine solely for the production of wine,[2] while since 2013 Ancient Georgian traditional Qvevri wine making method is included in world heritage list of the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation (UNESCO).[3] Till now ‘Georgia is the only country in the world where winemaking methods that were developed up to 8,000 years ago have not only never been abandoned but remain in many ways best practice.’[4]
[1] “Discover the Secret Birthplace of Wine” <https://www.nationalgeographic.com/travel/ destinations/asia/georgia/sponsor-content-secret-birthplace-of-wine/> accessed 13/07/2020.
[2] “World's oldest wine' found in 8,000-year-old jars in Georgia” <https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-41977709#:~:text=Scientists%20say%208%2C000-year-old,capital%2C%20Tbilisi%2C%20researchers%20said.> accessed 13/07/2020. For full research article See: Patrick McGovern, Mindia Jalabadze, Stephen Batiuk and others, “Early Neolithic wine of Georgia in the South Caucasus” (2017) PNAS <https://www.pnas.org/content/114/48/E10309.full> accessed 13/07/2020. See also “Raise a Glass to Georgia, the Official Cradle of Wine” <http://georgiatoday.ge/news/8213/Raise-a-Glass-to-Georgia%2C-the-Official-Cradle-of-Wine> accessed 13/07/2020.
[3] “Decision of the Intergovernmental Committee: 8.COM 8.13” <https://ich.unesco.org/en/ decisions/8.COM/8.13> accessed 13/07/2020. See also: “Ancient Georgian traditional Qvevri wine-making method” <https://ich.unesco.org/en/RL/ancient-georgian-traditional-qvevri-wine-making-method-00870>accessed 13/07/2020; Caroline Gilby MW, “Georgian winemaking method joins UNESCO heritage list” <https://www.decanter.com/wine-news/georgian-winemaking-method-joins-unesco-heritage-list-30889/> accessed 13/07/2020; Ketevan Charkhalashvili, “Qvevri Winemaking on UNESCO Cultural Heritage List” <https://www.georgianjournal.ge/arts-a-culture/25639-qvevri-winemaking-on-unesco-cultural-heritage-list.html> accessed 13/07/2020; “Qvevri”, <http://georgianwine.gov.ge/En/KvevriWine/Details/2> accessed 13/07/2020; “Raise a Glass to Georgia, the Official Cradle of Wine” <http://georgiatoday.ge/news/8213/Raise-a-Glass-to-Georgia%2C-the-Official-Cradle-of-Wine> accessed 13/07/2020; “Qvevri. Honoring an ancient process” <https://www.winesgeorgia.com/site/winemaking-tradition> accessed 13/07/2020.
[4] Andrew Jefford, “Georgian wines: older and wiser” <https://www.ft.com/content/7307e952-f50b-11e2-b4f8-00144feabdc0> accessed 13/07/2020.
Downloads
References
Books
View in Google Scholar
Paul Craig, Grainne de Burca, EU Law: Text, Cases, and Materials, (5th edn Oxford University Press 2011)
View in Google Scholar
Geoff Adams and others (eds), Wines of the World (2nd rev edn DK Publishing Inc, New York 2009)
View in Google Scholar
Pierre Spahni, The Common Wine Policy and Price Stabilization, (1988)
View in Google Scholar
Jancis Robinson (ed), Oxford Companion to Wine (2nd edn 1999)
View in Google Scholar
Tyler Colman, Wine Politics: How Governments, Environmentalists, Mobsters, and Critics Influence the Wines We Drink (University of California Press 2008)
View in Google Scholar
Leo A. Loubère, The Wine Revolution in France: The Twentieth Century (Princeton University Press 1990)
View in Google Scholar
Tim Unwin, Wine and the Vine: An Historical Geography of Viticulture and the Wine Trade (1991)
View in Google Scholar
Tom Stevenson, The Sotheby’s Wine Encyclopedia (4th edn 2005)
View in Google Scholar
Sylvie Bouneau, Bernard Christine, Dictionnaire des parlementaires d'Aquitaine sous la Troisième République (Presses Universitaires de Bordeaux 1998)
View in Google Scholar
Paul Lukacs, Inventing Wine: A New History of One of the World's Most Ancient Pleasures (W. W. Norton 2013)
View in Google Scholar
Charles K. Warner, The Winegrowers of France and the Government Since 1875 (1960)
View in Google Scholar
The Pocket Wine Encyclopedia, (Barnes & Noble 2006)
View in Google Scholar
Clive Coates MW, An Encyclopedia of the Wines and Domaines of France, (University of California Press 2000)
View in Google Scholar
Antonio Niederbacher, Wine in the European Community (Office for Official Publications of the European Communities 1983)
View in Google Scholar
გიორგი ბარისაშვილი, ღვინის დაყენება ქვევრში, (in Georgian) (ელკანა, თბილისი, 2010)
View in Google Scholar
გრიგოლ ჯანხოთელი, მეღვინეობა, (in Georgian) (მერანი-3, თბილისი, 1999)
View in Google Scholar
კ. მოდებაძე, მეღვინეობა, (in Georgian) (სახელმწიფო გამომცემლობა, თბილისი, 1948)
View in Google Scholar
И. Исаев, Государственная приемка продукции (in Russian) (Издательство Стандартов 1989)
View in Google Scholar
А. И. Якушев, Л. Н. Воронцов, Н. М. Федотов, Взаимозаменяемость, стандартизация и технические измерения (in Russian) (1987)
View in Google Scholar
В.В. Ткаченко, Роль стандартизации в ускорении научно-технического прогресса и повышении качества продукции (in Russian) (Издательство Стандартов 1988)
View in Google Scholar
В.Г. Мельников, Л.С. Казанов, Основы стандартизации, допуски, посадки и технические измерения, (in Russian) (Высшая школа 1978)
View in Google Scholar
Н.С. Козловский, А.Н. Виноградов, Основы стандартизации, допуски, посадки и технические измерения (in Russian) (1982)
View in Google Scholar
Ronald Grigor Suny, The Making of the Georgian Nation, (2nd edn Indiana University Press 1994)
View in Google Scholar
Donald Rayfield, Edge of Empires: A History of Georgia, (Reaktion Books London 2012)
View in Google Scholar
David Raic, Statehood and the Law of Self-Determination (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers 2002)
View in Google Scholar
Christian Walter, Antje von Ungern-Sternberg, Kavus Abushov (eds), Self-Determination and Secession in International Law (Oxford University Press 2014)
View in Google Scholar
Articles
View in Google Scholar
Jefrey A. Munsie, “A Brief History of the International Regulation of Wine Production” (Work, Harvard Law School 2002)
View in Google Scholar
Kevin H. Josel, New Wine in Old Bottles: The Protection of France’s Wine Classification System Beyond Its Borders, 12 B.U. Int’l L.J. 471, 473 (1994)
View in Google Scholar
Jim Chen, A Sober Second Look at Appellations of Origin: How the United States Will Crash France's Wine and Cheese Party, (Minn. J. Global Trade 1996)
View in Google Scholar
Antoine Vialard, Regulating Quality Wines in European and French Laws, 19 N. ILL. U. L. (1999)
View in Google Scholar
Treaties
View in Google Scholar
EC Treaty (Treaty of Rome)
View in Google Scholar
The Treaty on European Union (Maastricht Treaty)
View in Google Scholar
Legal Acts
View in Google Scholar
Council Regulation 24/62
View in Google Scholar
Council Regulation 816/70
View in Google Scholar
Council Regulation 817/70
View in Google Scholar
Council Regulation 1338/70
View in Google Scholar
Council Regulation 2005/70
View in Google Scholar
Council Regulation 1162/76
View in Google Scholar
Council Regulation 1163/76
View in Google Scholar
Council Regulation 454/80
View in Google Scholar
Council Regulation 456/80
View in Google Scholar
Council Regulation 822/87
View in Google Scholar
Council Regulation 823/87
View in Google Scholar
GOST 1.0-68
View in Google Scholar
GOST 13918-88
View in Google Scholar
GOST 12134-87
View in Google Scholar
GOST 28685-90
View in Google Scholar
GOST 7208-84
View in Google Scholar
Decree #1942 of 27 June 1990, amendment for GOST 7208-84
View in Google Scholar
GOST 7208-70
View in Google Scholar
RST 247-77
View in Google Scholar
Amendment #2 for RST 247-77
View in Google Scholar
Act of Restoration of State Independence of Georgia
View in Google Scholar
Code de la consommation
View in Google Scholar
Reports
View in Google Scholar
statistical report on world vitiviniculture (International Organisation of Vine and Wine - OIV) 14. Available at <http://oiv.int/public/medias/6782/oiv-2019-statistical-report-on-world-vitiviniculture.pdf> accessed 26/07/2020
View in Google Scholar
Internet Sources
View in Google Scholar
Jan Conway, “Global wine consumption in 2019, by country” <https://www.statista.com/statistics/858743/global-wine-consumption-by-country/> accessed 16/07/2020
View in Google Scholar
“Wine consumed in pure alcohol, litres per capita, age 15+” <https://gateway.euro.who.int/en/indicators/hfa_428-3052-wine-consumed-in-pure-alcohol-litres-per-capita-age-15plus/visualizations/#id=20008> accessed 16/07/2020
View in Google Scholar
Jan Conway, “Leading countries in wine production worldwide 2019” <https://www.statista.com/statistics/240638/wine-production-in-selected-countries-and-regions/> accessed 26/07/2020
View in Google Scholar
Andrew Jefford, "2017 must be one of the most disaster-strewn years since phylloxera" <https://www.decanter.com/premium/andrew-jefford-2017-vintage-383485/ ?fbclid=IwAR34Nbc9B3l9l7Lt8JAyhcB1tGpsXhuU24s42qDQI3E2iJXb0AROE0mowBk> accessed 26/07/2020
View in Google Scholar
W.J. Stewart "common customs tariff." Collins Dictionary of Law. 2006. <https://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/common+customs+tariff> accessed 11 January 2021
View in Google Scholar
"Publication Office of The European Union" <https://op.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/afd4e017-1798-4f7e-9e14-b4bd1d12256f/language-en> accessed 10 January 2021
View in Google Scholar
“History of Wine” <http://vins-france.com/en/wines-in-france/history/> accessed 17 October 2020
View in Google Scholar
L'Institut national de l'origine et de la qualité <https://www.inao.gouv.fr> accessed 20 April 2020
View in Google Scholar
Légifrance <https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/id/LEGITEXT000006069565/> accessed 11 January 2021
View in Google Scholar
“Chaptalization - History” <http://www.liquisearch.com/chaptalization/history> accessed 27 January 2020
View in Google Scholar
Sue Lynn Carty “Chaptalization” <http://wine.lovetoknow.com/Chaptalization> accessed 27 January 2020
View in Google Scholar
'Vin de Table' <https://www.winespectator.com/glossary/show/id/vin_de_table> accessed 6 March 2021
View in Google Scholar
'Vin de France (formerly Vin de Table)' <https://www.wine-searcher.com/regions-vin+de+france+-+vin+de+table> accessed 6 March 2021
View in Google Scholar
"Кодекс, Электронный фонд правовой и нормативно-технической документации" (in Russian) <http://docs.cntd.ru/document/1200088352> accessed 24 March 2021
View in Google Scholar
“History” <https://www.rst.gov.ru/portal/eng//home/about/history> accessed 15 February 2021
View in Google Scholar
“Gosstandart (GOST)” <https://ihsmarkit.com/ products/gost-standards.html> accessed 15 February 2021
View in Google Scholar
"ГОСТы и стандарты" (in Russian) <https://standartgost.ru> accessed 15 February 2021
View in Google Scholar
"Библиотека нормативной документации" (in Russian) <https://files.stroyinf.ru> accessed 15 February 2021 "База ГОСТов" (in Russian) <https://allgosts.ru> accessed 15 February 2021
View in Google Scholar
"Саришвили Наскид Григорьевич" (in Russian) <http://www.cnshb.ru/AKDiL/akad/base/RS/000440.shtm> accessed 21 February 2021
View in Google Scholar
Ashlie Hughes, 'In 1936, Joseph Stalin Created the Proletariat’s Very Own ‘Champagne’', 14 July 2020 <https://vinepair.com/articles/stalin-soviet-champagne/> accessed 29 August 2021
View in Google Scholar
Jessica Gingrich, 'How Stalin and the Soviet Union Created a Champagne for the Working Class', 5 November 2019 <https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/champagne-in-soviet-union> accessed 29 August 2021
View in Google Scholar
Richard Woodard, 'Russia to stop using ‘Soviet Champagne’ name', 28 October 2011, <https://www.decanter.com/wine-news/russia-votes-to-drop-shampanskoye-34246/> accessed 29 August 2021 James von Geldern, 'Soviet Champagne' (Essay) <http://soviethistory.msu.edu/1934-2/soviet-champagne/> accessed 29 August 2021
View in Google Scholar
'Soviet Champagne History', 28 October 2009, <https://www.wineterroirs.com/2009/10/sovietchampagne.html> accessed 29 August 2021
View in Google Scholar
"Виноградарство и виноделие Грузии" (in Russian) <http://www.sovietwine.com/winery/gssr.html> accessed 13 March 2021
View in Google Scholar
"Qvevri" <http://georgianwine.gov.ge/En/KvevriWine/Details/2> accessed 19 March 2021
View in Google Scholar
"Республиканский стандарт" (in Russian) <https://www.ngpedia.ru/id477214p1.html> accessed 23 March 2021
View in Google Scholar
'National Scientific Library - TSU' <http://opac.sciencelib.ge/cgi-bin/koha/opac-search.pl?q=ccl=pb%3AГосплан%20Грузинской%20ССР%2C%20&sort_by=pubdate_dsc&limit=se:%20Республиканский%20стандарт%20Грузинской%20ССР> accessed 4 September 2021
View in Google Scholar
"Винодельческая промышленность" (in Russian) <https://www.booksite.ru/fulltext/1/001/008/ 005/191.htm> accessed 13 March 2021
View in Google Scholar
James von Geldern "Anti-Alcohol Campaign" <http://soviethistory.msu.edu/1985-2/anti-alcohol-campaign/> accessed 5 March 2021
View in Google Scholar
Илья Кирилин "Ни капли: история сухих законов" (in Russian) <https://swn.ru/articles/istoriya-suhih-zakonov> accessed 5 March 2021
View in Google Scholar
Calin Aneculaesei "Destroying Tradition: The Soviet Anti-Alcohol Campaigns" <https://historyofyesterday.com/destroying-tradition-the-soviet-anti-alcohol-campaigns-e6fec177135d> accessed 6 March 2021
View in Google Scholar
Dan Piepenbring "Booze in the USSR" <https://www.theparisreview.org/blog/2017/04/19/booze-in-the-ussr/> accessed 6 March 2021
View in Google Scholar
"20 лет назад виноградники превращались в поля" (in Russian) <https://podrobnosti.ua/251685-20-let-nazad-vinogradniki-prevraschalis-v-polja.html> accessed 6 March 2021
View in Google Scholar
"Россия без алкоголя: неравный бой с зеленым змием" (in Russian) <https://www.bbc.com/russian/russia/2015/05/150515_gorbachev_alcohol_campaign_history> accessed 8 March 2021
View in Google Scholar
Downloads
Published
Versions
- 29-12-2022 (3)
- 29-12-2022 (2)
- 19-10-2022 (1)
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2022 Nikoloz Parsadanishvili

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.