Triumph of legal formalism – threat to the security of the legal order
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.34858/api.1.2022.1Słowa kluczowe:
law; spirit of law; letter of the law; formalism; apologetics of law; dualism; constitutional justiceAbstrakt
The article deals with the relationship between the spirit of law and the letter of the law. The dualism of the spirit of law and the letter of the law lies in the discrepancy between their nature. The spirit of law expresses ideas, principles, symbols and values that can be regulative. Whereas the letter of the law is a set of documented norms that have a constitutive essence. The spirit of law is the fundamental basis of the legal consciousness of society. In law, as in art, which affects the consciousness and behavior of a person, the main thing is its spirit, meaning and image: only then the form of law acquires the fullness and integrity of its functional characteristics. The subject of the research is the categories “spirit of law” and “letter of law” in their regulatory sense. The purpose of this study is to substantiate the fundamental nature of the concept of “spirit of law” for the methodology of legal research, legal consciousness and the mechanism of legal regulation. The methodology for researching the spirit of law presupposes an adequate selection of means of knowledge. You cannot study the spirit of law with the tools of materialism or economic determinism. For the study of the spirit of law, the spiritual-moral, axiological, metaphysical, systemic methods and the method of synthesis are preferred. When the spirit of law is denied, the legal system of society ceases to meet the elementary requirements of the formation of a person’s legal consciousness, his improvement and spiritual health. With the dominance of a dogmatic, positivist approach to law, it is generally impossible to understand how law functions and achieves a regulatory effect.
Pobrania
Bibliografia
On Education in the Russian Federation: Federal Law of December 29, 2012 No. 273-FZ // Collected Legislation. 2013. No. 1. Art. 1254.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
On patriotic education in the Lipetsk region: Law of the Lipetsk region of July 23, 2018 No. 190-OZ // Official Internet portal of legal information http://www.pravo.gov.ru. 25.07.2018.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
On the protection of the health of the population of the Krasnodar Territory: The law of the Krasnodar Territory of June 30, 1997 // Kubanskie Novosti. No. 197. 10.21.1997.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
On the protection of public morality: Law of the Altai Territory of December 4, 1995 // Altai truth. 1995.6 December.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
On Approval of the Concept of Solving the Complex Problem" Formation of Conditions for the Development of Spirituality, High Culture and Moral Health of the Population of the Novosibirsk Region: Orders of the Governor of the Novosibirsk Region of June 10, 2009 No. 150-r // Electronic Fund of Legal and Normative and Technical Documentation:http://docs.cntd.ru/document/5432887
Zobacz w Google Scholar
On the approval of the Concept of spiritual, moral and patriotic education of students in educational institutions of the Rostov region with a cadet and Cossack component: Decree of the government of the Rostov region of November 15, 2012 No. 1018 // Our time. No. 674-677. 2012.22 November.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Bachinin V.A. Encyclopedia of Philosophy and Sociology of Law. SPb: Nauka, 2006. 380 p.;
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Bainiyazov R.S. Legal awareness and legal mentality in Russia. Saratov: Izdatelskij dom SSU, 2001. 168 p.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Baranov V.M., Remizov P.V. Legislative critic: doctrine, practice, technique. M.: Shishka, 2018. 188 p.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Bazhenov A.A. “Words of Law and Grace” by Hilarion; Ideological and philosophical heritage of Hilarion. (Vols. 1-2). Kiev, 1984. 250 p.; 320 p.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Bergel J.L. General theory of law. M.: Norma, 2009. 186 p.;
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Bondar N.S. The letter and spirit of the Russian Constitution // Journal of Russian Law. 2013. No. 11. P. 36-39;
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Dubinina E.N. The essence of the process of legalization of relations of modern society // History of State and Law. 2008. No. 10. P. 9 – 11.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Dyugi L. Constitutional law. General theory of the state. M., 1908. 432 p.;
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Hart G. Positivism and the differentiation of law and morality // Jurisprudence. 2005. No. 3. P. 18-24;
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Hegel. The phenomenology of the spirit. M.: Yuridicheskaya literatura, 1959. 700 p.;
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Kosarev A.I. Historiosophy of state and law. M.: Yuridicheskij Dom, 2019. 168 p.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Kosarev A.I. History of state and law of foreign countries. Moscow: YURLITINFORM, 2012.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Malein N.S. Legally Protected Interest. Soviet state and law. 1980. No. 1. P. 27–34.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Maltsev G.V. Moral foundations of law. M.: Norma, 2013. 280 p.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Medushevskaya N.F. Search for the spiritual foundations of law in Russian legal thought // History of State and Law. 2007. No. 14. P. 18-22
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Montesquieu S. On the spirit of laws. M.: Prospekt, 1999. 304 p.;
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Radbruch G. Philosophy of Law. M.: Yurajt, 2004. 244 p.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Sinyukov V.N. Russian legal system. M.: Prospekt, 2010. 260 p.;
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Ter-Akopov A.A. Crimes and problems of non-physical causality in criminal law. Moscow: Yurkniga, 2003. 315 p.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Tikhomirov Yu.A. Law: forecasts and risks. M.: Norma, 2018. 288 p.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Velichko A.M. Moral and national foundations of law. SPb.: Nauka, 2002. 290 p.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Vysheslavtsev B.P. Ethics of the transformed eros Moscow: Respublika, 1994. 220 p.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Zorkin V.D. Right against chaos. M.: Prospekt, 2018. 208 p.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Pobrania
Opublikowane
Wersje
- 29-12-2022 - (5)
- 29-12-2022 - (4)
- 19-10-2022 - (3)
- 19-10-2022 - (2)
- 19-10-2022 - (1)
Numer
Dział
Licencja
Prawa autorskie (c) 2022 Vitaliy Sorokin
Utwór dostępny jest na licencji Creative Commons Uznanie autorstwa 4.0 Międzynarodowe.
